I feel tempted to give
White Oleander a better rating, but after evaluating
the entire film, I have no choice but to only give it a
light two and a half bucket recommendation. The
performances are dead on, and are some of the best of the
entire year, but the screenplay is much fluffier than it
pretends and is supposed to be. The cast made an excellent
effort, that I must compliment, but the direction,
production, and set design are poorly done. The camera
angles feature the horrendous backgrounds more than they
do the actors, there is little to no music utilized in the
long running length at all, and everything looks like it
was put together by a couple of high school
video-production students. The great performances are all
it has to offer.
I loved the
trailer for the film, which I saw at least ten times
before the real deal. I was enticed by the three minute
scrapbook of clips, and expected that it would be a
wonderful piece. Don’t get me wrong, I didn’t think
White Oleander was bad; it just wasn’t what I
expected it to be. Maybe my high expectations contributed
the average result, but beware: the strongest and most
powerful material is used in the trailer, and the entire
flick provides much less than the few tidbits shown in the
previews. Another thing that was misleading about the
trailer was the high usage of the sweet sounding theme
song which is only played during the
end credits in the real movie.
The story is
based on a novel by Janet Fitch, which to my knowledge is
more thoroughly written than the screenplay, and is in a
more chronological order, one thing that the film lacked.
It is about a girl named Astrid (Allison Lohman), whose
mother named Ingrid (Michelle Pfeiffer) is convicted of
murder when she kills her boyfriend who was cheating on
her. Jail is not at all traumatizing for Ingrid, but the
foster homes that Astrid must live in are terrible to her.
She lives with a woman named Starr at first, who is a
southern bell with fake breasts and skimpy clothing, even
though she is much too old for what she wears. She tries
to turn Astrid into a preppy teenage girl, similar to her
other daughter, but ends up trying to kill her when she
starts to think that she is cheating on her husband. The
adoptions agency prohibits Astrid from living with Starr’s
family anymore after she takes a bullet to the heart, so
she is sent to live with Claire Richards (Renee Zellweger),
who she truly likes. She is finally living her life to the
fullest, but then the plot takes a dramatic turn when
Claire commits suicide when she finds that her husband is
cheating on her. Astrid is trapped and has no where to go,
she can not get along with any family who takes her in.
Her life has no sense of direction. Will her sole ever be
fulfilled or is she bound to be a prostitute on Sunset
Boulevard? The powerful ending scene has the answers.
There were
four great performances in the flick. They were put on by
Michelle Pfeiffer, Renee Zellweger, Robin Wright Penn, and
Allison Lohman. Pfieffer was great because of the way she
presented the confidence that her character had, the
strong spoken and perfectly annunciated speech of Ingrid
was the best part of the whole movie. Penn was able to
accomplish a much different personality, that of a slut,
and let me tell you; no one could do it better than she
did. The woman that she plays, Starr, is a southern bell
who is striving for sex, but tries to cover it up with
dialogue about rubbish on Jesus and the Bible. This
material was not only strangely believable, but supported
one of the best performances of the year. Zellweger on the
other hand, played a kind and loving individual, whose
nice ways are only a way to busy her self to cover up all
of the stress that she undergoes. There was a certain dash
of cockiness to her performance that made the role suit
her perfectly. Lohman should win “Best Actress” at the
Academy Awards for her simply inspiring work. The
emotionally destroyed Astrid is one of the most beautiful
characters ever created, and Lohman’s narration was the
most profound of the last decade. All of the performances
put together were a stick of dynamite, which blasted every
other actor and actress team of the year out of the water.
When its Oscar time, I guarantee you that we will see
several of these women nominated.
White Oleander comes up short of a good movie, but its
wonderful performances make it worth seeing at a matinee
or renting when on video. In short, the production and
direction are terrible, but Lohman, Pfeiffer, Penn, and
Zellweger give it its unique flair. I enjoyed it, but
didn’t worship it; and a light recommendation is an
adequate fit for its average material.
-Danny, Bucket Reviews