FROM THE BUCKET REVIEWS ARCHIVE
Review: The Snowtown Murders
Danny Baldwin · November 8, 2011
Originally reviewed on November 8, 2011.
Midway through the Australian film The Snowtown Murders (formerly titled simply Snowtown), about the serial killer John Bunting (here played by Daniel Henshall), I thought to myself: “What would David Fincher have done differently?” The reaction was not so arbitrary, given that Fincher has made two of the best films on serial killers in recent history and arguably all of film history. As The Snowtown Murders moved from one brutally violent scene to another, dramatizing Bunting’s crimes with repetitious abandon, I found my answer: Fincher wouldn’t have made the movie at all.
I am all for movies that depict life in even the worst of forms, but they must do so for the purpose of allowing audiences to understand something that they otherwise would not have realized. Through its relentless depictions of Bunting’s crimes and his relationship with a 16-year-old accomplice (Lucas Pittaway), The Snowtown Murders doesn’t tell us anything we don’t already know. The two main themes that co-writer/director Justin Kurzel seems to extoll are that murder is heinous and that serial killers (like cult leaders) are often charismatic and alluring — hardly new ideas. Furthermore, given that this is a drama, not a documentary, viewers can’t even claim to have experienced a comprehensive chronicle of Bunting’s life. Thus, the experience of watching The Snowtown Murders amounts to a sort of masochism for the viewer — how much violent content are they willing to endure for little potential benefit?
In most technical respects, the movie is impeccably made, but for what? Yes, actor Daniel Henshall–a complete unknown to American audiences–is terrifying as Bunting, a man who was both a monster and a dynamo in the community. Henshall chills the spine in nearly every scene he is in — from the murders themselves, to those that find him grandstanding about the ills of local pedophiles (his main victims). Yes, Lucas Pittaway gives an equally striking debut performance as the neighbor kid who Bunting was able to coax under his wing. And yes, Kurzel’s direction is as gritty and disquieting as you’d expect for the material. But when the end result of all these great elements is a film that puts the viewer through hell without any accompanying enlightenment, have they not been completely wasted? I think so, and as such, The Snowtown Murders is a failure.
