FROM THE BUCKET REVIEWS ARCHIVE
Review: Pirates of the Caribbean - On Stranger Tides
Danny Baldwin · May 25, 2011

Don’t remember the terribly labyrinthian story from the last Pirates of the Caribbean movie? Well, no need to go back and re-watch it, because neither did franchise screenwriters Ted Elliot and Terry Rossio. Instead of picking up where their characters last left off–at world’s end, was it?–the duo have placed Johnny Depp’s Captain Jack Sparrow at an unspecified future point in On Stranger Tides, likely so they wouldn’t have to address the departure of co-stars stars Keira Knightley and Orlando Bloom. While the resulting story is definitely easier to follow than those of the past two installments (which were complicated, if not complex), this is because Elliot and Rossio have pulled a complete 180 and penned a work of utter simplicity. It is rather surprising to learn that the movie was “suggested by” an unrelated 1987 pirate novel (for which it was titled); did they really need source material to write a story that effectively amounts to a race?
Indeed, that is the entire plot of the movie: a straightforward, three-way race. The Spanish, an English ship led by Geoffrey Rush’s now-privateer Captain Barbosa, and a rogue ship led by the notorious pirate Blackbeard (Ian McShane) are all in pursuit of a rumored Fountain of Youth. After narrowly escaping arrest when impersonating a judge to save his old first mate from being hanged, Sparrow ends up on Blackbeard’s ship. (Getting into why, for the purposes of this review, would be a fruitless exercise, as this isn’t very interesting and it would be even less so if you ended up seeing the movie.) At any rate, also aboard is Angelica (Penélope Cruz), who apparently had a romantic past with Jack and has also discovered that she is Blackbeard’s daughter. And together they… sail! Yes, the story is anemic. There are a few distinguishing features thrown into the mix (Siren-esque mermaids, anyone?), but for the most part, it’s one tired dialogue exchange or overplayed pirate action sequence after another. The special effects are impressive, but by this point, we have all seen enough $200 million movies not to care.
The director is Rob Marshall, a filmmaker whose conception of the epic is “a long movie with lavish visuals.” There is no extended suspense, no scope, no timeless feeling to Pirates of the Caribbean: On Stranger Tides, as was the case with Marshall’s 2005 drama Memoirs of a Geisha and his 2009 musical Nine. In other words, aside from the extremely basic central thread of the story–they are on a quest to find the Fountain of Youth–there is not the sense of journey vital to an epic’s success. The film simply feels like one programmatic action set-piece after another, as if to give audiences “what they want” without any understanding of how this should be assembled. Marshall can’t even direct the one piece of the puzzle that doesn’t need any directing — Johnny Depp, who (need I remind you) once received an Oscar nomination for this character. Captain Jack’s charms and winking homosexuality are almost completely lost in this movie, as he becomes just another cog in the blockbuster machine. This is quite ironic given that On Stranger Tides is the first entry in the series in which he has actually been the protagonist. But under Marshall’s incompetent control, this Pirates of the Caribbean all too easily allows viewers to forget just what a treasure Captain Jack can be.
And the 3-D — don’t even get me started. Given that Marshall chose to natively shoot the film using the technology–in other words, it wasn’t forced on him by Disney in the form of a post-production conversion–I think that criticizing the film itself for its use of 3-D is fair. Because it was shot using 3-D cameras, the main effect is the illusion of depth (the way it should be, proponents of the technology say). But what does this do for the audience? In 100 years of 2-D moviemaking, could we really not imagine onscreen spatial relationships well enough? In fact, it a borderline insult to the audience’s intelligence to assume they need a cheap glasses-trick to become “sucked in” to a world. Ironically, 3-D will have the exact opposite effect on most viewers of the movie, removing them from the world as they deal with their uncomfortable and terribly dark glasses (which make the night scenes close to unwatchable, even at IMAX-illumination levels). There are a few instances in which objects (usually swords) pop out at the viewer, but they are so obvious that they lack the sense of surprise needed for plane-penetrating 3-D to thrill.
Parts two and three of the Pirates of the Caribbean franchise may have gotten a little out of hand plot-wise, with running times of nearly three hours, but they were always at least fun to watch. By contrast, this fourth installment is a real labor for the viewer, both mentally (due to the soulless story) and physically (thanks to those damn glasses). Captain Jack should have sailed off in the distance one movie ago.
* * *
Pirates of the Caribbean: On Stranger Tides (2011, USA). Produced by Jerry Bruckheimer, John DeLuca, Ted Elliot, Chad Oman, Melissa Reid, Terry Rossio, Pat Sandston, Mike Stenson, and Barry H. Waldman. Directed by Rob Marshall. Written for the screen by Ted Elliot and Terry Rossio. Characters by Ted Elliot, Terry Rossio, Stuart Beattie, and Jay Wolpert. Suggested by the novel by Tim Powers. Starring Johnny Depp, Penélope Cruz, Geoffrey Rush, Ian McShane, Kevin McNally, and Sam Claflin. Distributed by Walt Disney Pictures. Rated PG-13, with a running time of 137 minutes.
