Skip to content
Bucket Reviews — Reviews and criticism by Danny BaldwinTHE ARCHIVE
Reviews · essays · dispatches
← Back to the archive

FROM THE BUCKET REVIEWS ARCHIVE

Review: Y Tu Mamá También

Danny Baldwin · Publication date unknown — likely 2003

Not Rated | 105 mins

Original Bucket Rating

Y Tu Mamá También

I am, literally, shocked. So I finally get to seeing Y Tu Mamá También, after it receives mass critical acclaim and worship around the world. And after it was over, there was no doubt in my mind that it was a good movie, but frankly, anyone who thinks it’s revolutionary must be smoking crack.

I caught it when it aired on the Independent Film Channel, uncut and in full-form, about three weeks ago. Since then, I’ve read many reviews on it, and still do not understand the majority of critics’ positions. Here’s what a few of them wrote:

“…another trumpet blast that there may be a New Mexican Cinema a-bornin'.”–Roger Ebert

“...an original, harsh, funny slant on the traditional road movie, as experienced by two Mexican teens and their gorgeous 28-year-old tagalong." –Norm Schrager

"...is fast, funny, unafraid of sexuality and finally devastating."–Elvis Mitchell

Let’s be honest, here. Y Tu Mamá También is a funny, witty comedy with a bunch of racy scenes thrown in. I wouldn’t hesitate to call it a raunchy teen movie; it’s not profound, it’s not amazing—it’s just a wonderful trip. The writing is excellent, but there is also a tremendous amount of errors to be found in this film. For one, the tone is totally misguided. While Alfonso Cuaron may have a way with words, his directing skills do not measure up. There’s also nothing touching about Y Tu Mamá También, and this is definitely a problem. I didn’t feel for the characters in quite the way that others did; I didn’t find their dreams to be all that exciting, compared to what’s imposed.

All in all, this is definitely a flick that’s worth seeing, but I’d strongly advise against it if you’re looking for something life-affirming. I am a member of Y Tu Mamá También’s audience, but I’m clearly more hesitant about liking it than others.