Skip to content
Bucket Reviews — Reviews and criticism by Danny BaldwinTHE ARCHIVE
Reviews · essays · dispatches
← Back to the archive

FROM THE BUCKET REVIEWS ARCHIVE

Review: Cold Mountain

Danny Baldwin · Publication date unknown — likely 2004

Rated R | 155 mins

Original Bucket Rating

Cold Mountain

There’s always a movie each year that opens up to one of the best beginnings in film’s history, but then ends up being disappointing. And I don’t mean for you to take that lightly, either. Cold Mountain starts with dynamite, a gigantic blast of success on the parts of director Anthony Minghella and cast members Nicole Kidman and Jude Law, whose natural chemistry overflows the screen in a sensuous and touching, graceful manner. The greatness of the picture continues on for almost an hour and a half, captivating us with the genuine emotions of love, war, and confliction, in a brutal and uncertain time. However, when Minghella brings a few more characters into the mix, the experience becomes more rough and unpolished than it should be. Cold Mountain is the 2003 equivalent of Martin Scrosese’s Gangs of New York, which was released around the same time in 2002. Both films startle and baffle us with epic premises and visceral plots, but they stumble into unsatisfying conclusions, failing to recognize how great they could’ve been. The two are still very good movies, however. This one certainly deserves to be watched by many.

The characters here aren’t as deep as the tale in which they embody, but being the talented man that he is, Minghella is able to cover this up, with his illusive storytelling abilities.

Kidman plays Ada Monroe, a young woman who moves from Charleston, West Virginia to Cold Mountain, North Carolina soon before the breakout of the Civil War. There, she falls in love with Inman (Jude Law), and the two only begin to develop a relationship, even though it’s evident that the sparks between them are flying high. However, when the War Between the States does commence, Inman, like all the other Southern males, must go and fight. Through the many hardships, Ada sends him letters, constantly expressing her passion towards him. When he becomes injured in the war, and the sweet southern voice of the woman aiding him begins to read a piece of his mail from his lover, slowly transferring into Ada’s herself, it becomes apparent to him that he should try return home. Even though it may be chocked full of melodramatic, hallmark Hollywood moments up to this point in time, Cold Mountain is one hell of an exhilarating picture.

But, of course, Minghella must maintain an epic feel, and this is where he goes wrong. Since he still has some empty space to fill up before his film reaches a conclusion, he throws some dry material into the mix, making the movie feel more like an experimental concoction than an accomplished piece of art.

So what does he decide to add in to kill some time? A comedic relief—by the name of Ruby Thewes (Renée Zellweger)—the character from hell. Along with Ruby comes her father and his posse, whose personalities are almost as generic as hers. In fact, they negatively influence the ending of the film in such a prominent way, it’s hard to deny that their creation was nothing short of a devastating mistake.

I suppose you could call Zellweger brilliant, because, somehow, she keeps a character who should’ve ruined the movie from doing so. Her co-stars’ work often comes off as better because the quality of their roles is much purer, but she’s the real star of the film. The one thing that Ruby taught me during this film was that an actor’s performance has a greater impact on the end result of a film than the written personality that they capture. Good roles are hard to come by, but great acting is what should really be remembered. If I was solely grading the script of Cold Mountain, I’d rate it about two buckets. Instead, I give the movie three. This, alone, proves that it’s been brought to life in good hands.

It would be a crime if I didn’t mention the realism of the war scenes somewhere, also. The gruesomeness of the opening battle, in particular, is striking. Too many movies about the Civil War try to depict it as being a clean event. That material has a place on the History Channel, but not in multiplexes (with the exception of Gettysburg, which I consider to be one of the greatest war films of all-time). In a sense, the contrast between these gritty and accurate battle sequences, showcased in this film, and the somewhat superficial excess scenes, works to its advantage. Cold Mountain almost thrives upon its mistakes. It may have taken me writing this review to realize it, but this movie deserves a significant place in every moviegoer’s heart, even though it’s desperately imperfect. Whatever Cold Mountain’s flaws, we can accept and appreciate it. I can only hope that this will be enough for the majority of moviegoers.