Skip to content
Bucket Reviews — Reviews and criticism by Danny BaldwinTHE ARCHIVE
Reviews · essays · dispatches
← Back to the archive

FROM THE BUCKET REVIEWS ARCHIVE

Review: Elf

Danny Baldwin · Publication date unknown — likely 2003

Rated PG | 95 mins

Original Bucket Rating

Elf

Elf is disgustingly sweet, sugar-filled and atrocious. By its end, we feel as though we’ve consumed a dozen Krispy Kreme donuts and are about to dive into another box. The first forty five minutes are enjoyable, but after that, the material becomes sickeningly intolerable. Elf does have its moments, most of which are very funny, but these are certainly not worth the price of a ticket. Once you’ve seen the trailer, you’ve witnessed pieces of almost every humorous skit. And the truth is that I’d rather sit through the trailer fifteen times in a row than see this movie again. I wish I could say more on its behalf.

In my opinion, Will Farrell is one of the best comedians of our time. Whether you hate him or you love him, you must admit that he’s likeable, dopily amusing, and expressive when performing. Whether it be in Saturday Night Live skits or films, he knows how to make an audience laugh. He molds a handful of laughs in Elf and is about the only guy on the planet who could play this role, but the script is so insanely bad, he is rarely able to salvage the well-being of the picture. I hope that the second installment in the Old School franchise proves to be a better use of his many talents.

In a year, Elf will be a fine Christmas rental for the whole family. Just make sure that your DVD player’s scene-skipper button isn’t broken.