FROM THE BUCKET REVIEWS ARCHIVE
Review: The Sisterhood of the Traveling Pants
Danny Baldwin · Publication date unknown — likely 2005


Rated PG | 119 mins
Yes, it’s true: The Sisterhood of the Traveling Pants is more than just your average pre-teen chick-flick. The movie is genuine, sincere, and often poignant. Centering on the lives of four teenage friends during a summer they spend away from each other, connected by a pair of Fed-Exed jeans that strangely fit them all, it surprisingly avoids most of the typical conventions that plague this type of material. However, this turns out to be both a blessing and a burden. Despite being original, the director of The Sisterhood of the Traveling Pants, Ken Kwapis, frankly doesn’t know how to manage all four stories well on a linear thread. The material is ingenious and effective by itself, but it isn’t presented in a balanced enough way to form a polished product. The film goes on for a half hour longer than it needs to and dwells on its most ineffective passages (especially those which feature the love interest in Blake Lively’s story or America Ferrera’s melodramatic overacting). The only story-thread that completely worked for me was that which featured Alexis Bledel’s Lena, who moves to Greece for the summer to spend some time with family and ends up falling for the grandson of a man that they have had a grudge against for years. Still, I also deeply enjoyed that of Amber Tamblyn’s Tibby as well, if only for the “Joan of Arcadia” star’s humorous, wry wit. Had The Sisterhood of the Traveling Pants been able to be as consistent as it is when it features these two characters, it could’ve actually been rather great. As it stands, the movie has too much to offer to be called “disposable”, but it’s also too flawed to be called “exceptional”. I’ll settle for “noteworthy”.
