Skip to content
Bucket Reviews — Reviews and criticism by Danny BaldwinTHE ARCHIVE
Reviews · essays · dispatches
← Back to the archive

FROM THE BUCKET REVIEWS ARCHIVE

Review: Dark Water

Danny Baldwin · Publication date unknown — likely 2005 (inferred from U.S. opening and source collection)

Dark WaterDark Water

Rated PG-13 | 105 mins

IMDB Info

Without a particularly interesting plot—granted, the supernatural conflict found in this film is far more absorbing than that of any other American remake of a Japanese Horror movie—Dark Water manages to be quite a captivating and haunting motion picture. The reason for this is simple: it is expertly crafted, especially in terms of mood and atmosphere, as well as realistically performed. The beauty of Dark Water is that it doesn’t try to go for the same cheap scares that its peers do, but rather creates an eerie, dark realm of existence which deeply taps into the psyche. The premise is surprisingly human; rather than using the ghost-story which accompanies the apartment that the protagonist (Jennifer Connelly) and her daughter (Ariel Gage) move into as its main focus, the film concentrates more on a custody battle between she and her ex-husband (Dougray Scott).

Connelly crafts her character, named Dahlia, in such a convincing and assured manner that I have a hard time believing that she didn’t use personal experience—perhaps she based it on what went on with her first child?—as a point of reference. In fact, not a single member of the cast, which also includes John C. Reily as the owner of Dahlia’s apartment complex, disappoints at all. This, in itself, makes the more derivative elements of the Japanese Horror Genre found in Dark Water far more compelling than they ever have been before. It’s quite amazing to see how effective the somewhat hokey material, which usually comes across as utterly ridiculous in other movies, is when real, cutting emotion is actually involved. Likewise, such emotion also propels the tinted, stunning camerawork by Affonso Beato—which in its prime when it focuses on the geometric shapes of the film’s sublime setting of Roosevelt Island, New York—allowing it to ooze of a creepy feel. Even when Dark Water looses coherency at times, director Walter Salles (The Motorcycle Diaries) always uses its many assets to his advantage and the result is thoroughly fascinating. The movie represents what its peers—namely The Ring 2, which shared the same source-writer, and last year’s The Grudge—should’ve been.