FROM THE BUCKET REVIEWS ARCHIVE
The Influence of the Critic
Danny Baldwin · June 17, 2005

Critics Roger Ebert [left] and the late Gene Siskel [right].
"The critic is the only independent source of information. The rest is advertising."--Pauline Kael.
As an online film critic myself--despite the fact that I'm also one who hasn't updated his website in ages (but I promise to get up to speed soon)--I find myself in a position where I force myself to go to each and every movie that I have the oppurtunity to go to. I find it to be a matter of duty.
Wait...er...back up a little bit, will 'ya? Yeah, okay, so maybe I like seeing bad movies. It's the honest to God truth. To me, seeing good movies is the second-best thing in the world to do and seeing bad ones is the third-best thing to do. I don't think anyone really disagrees on what the first thing is.
Why? Because it allows me to confront my own biases towards the cinema, to be able to understand more about what I do like. Why is it that I can only enjoy a car chase when it is done with the utmost level of detail (meaning Paul Greengrass, not Michael Bay)? Why is it that mainsteam audiences like different things than the art-house? The ideas which come from cinema--although bad is a touchy word--are often more important than those which come from good cinema. If there is such a thing as an objectively bad movie, then are there artistically dumb people? The whole concept is continually fascinating.
Now comes the most important question of the hour: do I listen to other critics? I would love to say I don't; I would really love to be able to. But, the truth is: I do. And how can I deny it? I've tried not reading reviews or looking at star-ratings for weeks at a time and seeing movies without hearing a word about them. And it has been only torturous to do so. The only logical conclusion this leaves me to make is that I have a certain amount of dependency on the insights of others. Sure, my own kick ass--who doesn't think they have the best in the world when it comes to such a matter?--but I guess I just can't live without hearing what other people have to say about a film beforeI see it. While this doesn't go to say that I deny the chance to see a movie before it's released to the public at an advanced screening or a Film Festival, I certainly am interested by the fact that I cannot get past what others think. I disagree with the majority of critics a lot of the time (this previously 'blogged about Batman Begins is an example), so perhaps my own opinions are not entirely affected, psychologically, by what others say. But, playing devil's advocate to that thought, why else but critics is the reason for the fact that I have an urge to go back to Batman Begins and see if there was something wrong with my first impression? I rarely give movies a second chance if I agree with critics that they're awful; The Lizzie McGuire Movie is one of the rare cases in which I've revisited one of these and thought them to be great.
When it comes down to it all, the bottom line is: criticism proves endlessely fascinating. Why else would I spend *waste?* my time on it? Refining ones opinions about art is one of the most important things to do, creatively, and criticism is both the most direct and the most abstract illustration of such.
