Skip to content
Bucket Reviews — Reviews and criticism by Danny BaldwinTHE ARCHIVE
Reviews · essays · dispatches
← Back to the archive

FROM THE BUCKET REVIEWS ARCHIVE

Review: In America

Danny Baldwin · Publication date unknown — likely 2003

(Changed from 3 on 4/8) Rated PG-13 | 103 mins

Original Bucket Rating

In America

Ariel (Emma Bolger) and Christy (Sarah Bolger) are two little Irish girls, who have hopped the U.S./Canada border, and immigrated into the States with their parents (Paddy Cosidine and Samantha Morton), who buy an apartment in a rundown and dangerous Manhattan complex with literally all the money they have. Their father, Jim, is an actor, searching for any performing job that will allow him to start immediately. Their mother, Sarah, was a teacher back home, but she must settle for work at an ice cream parlor, in order to support the family. In many ways, the girls would like to adapt to the American way. They begin this transformation by going trick-or-treating in the building that they live in, but only one man opens the door for them. His name is Mateo (Djimon Hounsou), but he is referred to as “the man who screams,” by the occupants of the apartments surrounding his. This is because he keeps to himself, but yells so loud sometimes that the entire complex can hear him. However, he ironically befriends the girls and their family, and halts their transitioning, making them aware of many things about life, in general. In the midst of all of this, the four are also still mourning the death of their son/sibling, who was just two-years-old when he fatally fell down a flight of stairs.

In America works because the story is told in the eyes of the girls, making for a light tone. Because of their young age and simplistic knowledge about the world, they have little fear or worry. For example, take the incidence in which they go trick-or-treating. Despite the fact that they live in an unhealthy and frightful place, full of bad people, they still anxiously pound on everyone’s door multiple times, in an effort to get their fair share of Halloween candy. When he first meets them, Mateo shouts at the two as they chant the beloved words “trick-or-treat” at his apartment’s entryway. Rather than running away, as a normal person would, they increase their voices. They’re clearly intrigued by the new country, not afraid of it. Also: look at the time in which they first observe how badly their parents are in need of money. Ariel and Christy believe that their mom and dad will be able to work their way out of it, and that good times ensue in the future. If In America had been about Jim and Sarah’s hardships, then I guarantee you that I would’ve despised it. It could’ve been a blatant and helpless film, only discussing losers and their problems. But, instead, it’s an uplifting one. It’s made in such a way that will cause audiences to root for the girls and their parents. Ariel and Christy have hope, and this is key to the impression that the movie will make on its viewers. In America isn’t profound, but director Jim Sheridan, who has written this screenplay with his two daughters, and based it on their own personal experiences, knows how to find an emotional resonance with his audience. This, alone, makes it well-worth seeing; you will undeniably leave the theatre touched.

As good as the Bolger sisters are as Ariel and Christy, and Cosidine and Morton are as their parents, I believe that the best performance belongs to Hounsou. He creates one of the most wonderfully emotionally violent characters in the history of film. When with the girls, Mateo remains subtle and gentle, a model figure for them. But when contemplating his own personal issues, he has eruptions of confliction and craziness. There’s something remarkable about Hounsou’s work when this happens; his performance doesn’t only appear to be real, it feels real. Acting is certainly the strongest aspect of In America, and he is a terrific representation of this.

When we watch this movie, we feel as though we’ve been transported into a world of only optimism and ambition, in one of the most paradoxical of places. Our protagonists do not seem like dreamers, but wishers. And for the whole film, we’re merely wishing with them—wishing that their wishes come true.