Skip to content
Bucket Reviews — Reviews and criticism by Danny BaldwinTHE ARCHIVE
Reviews · essays · dispatches
← Back to the archive

FROM THE BUCKET REVIEWS ARCHIVE

Review: The Island

Danny Baldwin · Publication date unknown — likely July 2005

The Island

1 ½ Buckets

I guess I can understand that it’s in the destructive nature of director Michael Bay, the biggest hack to ever make movies with $100 million budgets, to want to blow stuff up. However, I do think that it’s about time that someone point out to him that whenever he does so, the given movie’s quality is annihilated as well. Whenever a filmmaker makes seven movies and Pearl Harbor is the best of the bunch, the gravity of the situation should definitely be acknowledged.

The Island is no different from Bay’s previous works; the only compliment that I can wholeheartedly pay it is that when compared to his last effort, Bad Boys II, it seems like a godsend. Even though it begins as a somewhat thoughtful meditation on cloning, by the time it reaches the end of its second act, its unfortunate fate has been cemented. During the first forty-five minutes of The Island, Bay is limited to the single setting of a facility in which living, growing clones are kept. As a result, he is forced to be subtle, allowing his two talented leads, Scarlett Johansson and Ewan McGregor, to carry an actual story. However, this doesn’t last for long. Johansson and McGregor’s characters soon discover the truth that they are clones, not survivors of a contaminated earth living in a sterile metropolis, as their memories have been programmed to believe. Not about to wait to be killed and have their body parts used to save the lives of their genetic identicals, they escape from the clone-colony and seek to find their real-life counterparts. Instead of swiftly crafting some cat-and-mouse-style action around the ensuing chase sequences between the duo and the company that created them, Bay opts to instill events in the plot which provoke the big explosions that he loves so much.

My main problem with the action in the film is not that it is improbable, but rather that it isn’t handled with an ounce of perspective. In one of the worst sketches in the film, a flying-motorcycle crashes into a skyscraper in the broad daylight of the city of Los Angeles. At this moment, not one member of the surrounding public questions what is happening and there are no media-vans rushing to the scene to take footage of the aftermath. This left me with one question: why should I care about the event? I knew that at its heart, The Island was a formula-movie that wouldn’t dare to kill off its main characters to make any kind of social statement; I didn’t need to worry about them. Bay gave me no reason to be concerned with what would happen to the villains of the story, the heads of the cloning corporation. The rest of the world certainly didn’t seem to be affected by the outcome of the events. As a result, I was simply left bored by and indifferent to the picture, unmotivated to pay any attention to cinematographer Mauro Fiore’s shaky camera-shots or Bay’s famously incoherent, uninteresting, and suspense-free montages.

The CGI used in the film is quite visually accomplished, but it’s almost a crime that something so beautiful has been forced to be a part of such an otherwise artistically-dreary product. The fact that the tremendous cast, which in addition to Johansson and McGregor includes the always superb Steve Buscemi and Djimon Hounsou, was wasted on it also marks a terribly unfortunate happening. For their reputations’ sake, I hope that The Island is soon forgotten. Its poor quality certainly makes it deserving of such a fate.