FROM THE BUCKET REVIEWS ARCHIVE
Review: Young Adult
Danny Baldwin · December 19, 2011

The comic antihero is among the most difficult cinematic archetypes to pull off, because it requires that the character be likable precisely because they are unredeemable. In other words, not only must the character be flawed, but the process of laughing at (as opposed to with) their flaws must be complex and involving enough to sustain a feature. Given our cultural proclivity to view character flaws as black-and-white, this is a difficult proposition.
Considering the sheer infectiousness of their previous protagonist (Juno MacGuff), it is pleasantly surprising that writer Diablo Cody and director Jason Reitman were able to transition to this meaner, trickier type of character so effortlessly. Even Reitman’s previous antihero, tobacco lobbyist Nick Naylor in Thank You for Smoking, seems like an angel compared to Young Adult’s Mavis Gary (a tremendous Charlize Theron).
Like the best characters of her kind, Mavis is a delusional narcissist whose behavior is based on primitive desires, and her schtick is so unrelenting that it never ceases to be funny. The popular girl in high school, Mavis left her Podunk hometown of Mercury, Minnesota for the considerably more metropolitan Minneapolis, where we first meet her as she awakens after the latest of presumably many drunken one-night stands.
Recognizing her emotional debt but severely misdiagnosing its cause, Mavis returns to Mercury to win back high school beau Buddy Slade (Patrick Wilson) — never mind that he now has a wife and a newborn. She reunites with him at the new sports-bar in town–a chain establishment for families–dressed as the expensive version of the oversexed trollop that might have impressed the high school Buddy.
What ensues is funny and shocking, because Mavis’ behavior is just as realistic as it is inhuman, as she vies for Buddy in the face of all reason and common courtesy. That is to say, for as unsympathetic as Mavis is throughout the film, she comes across as three-dimensional with actual problems — alcoholism, depression, and a serial inability to relate to others. The character works because Cody’s script never pulls any cheap-shots and Theron plays her with supreme nuance and conviction.
But the film’s definition comes just as much from the supporting characters as it does from Mavis. Buddy becomes her perfect foil, in a sense — he appropriately evolved from being an asshole jock in high school, whereas Mavis is tortured because she never reached the transition point and is now nothing without her popularity. Wilson nails the role, as Elizabeth Reaser does hers: Buddy’s modestly lovely wife Beth, who plays the drums in a band of expectant mothers.
The true revelation of the supporting cast, however, is Patton Oswalt. He plays Matt Frehauf, the chubby outcast who became the subject of intense local publicity when he was brutally beaten by classmates who (incorrectly) thought he was gay. Mavis forges a connection with him that verges on resembling something true, perhaps because they both continue to see life through the same frame they did in high school. Their conversations are the highlight of the film; Oswalt is every bit as good as Theron, never overdramatizing his role to the point at which it would undermine the comedy.
As with Juno, Reitman and Cody capture a strong sense of Midwestern regionalism, without the patronizing tone that accompanies it in so many other movies. In fact, Young Adult could be read as a deconstruction of the insipid “small-town girl who escapes to the big-city to do great things” mold. While Mavis is reasonably successful as a ghostwriter of young adult paperbacks, most of the people she left behind in Mercury are more mature and more self-actualized.
Young Adult’s specialness is cemented by the fact that Reitman and Cody elect not to cop out and sentimentalize the end, which seems to all too easily become a temptation when making a studio movie these days. Without spoiling anything, I will say that Mavis leaves the picture as nastily as she enters it. It’s nice to see a movie that remains resolute in its principles, cruel as they may be.
* * *
Young Adult (2011, USA). Produced by Brian Bell, Jason Blumenfeld, Diablo Cody, Helen Estabrook, Lianne Halfon, Nathan Kahane, Beth Kono, Kelli Konop, Mary Lee, John Malkovich, Mason Novick, Steven M. Rales, Jason Reitman, Russell Smith, and Charlize Theron. Directed by Jason Reitman. Written for the screen by Diablo Cody. Starring Charlize Theron, Patton Oswalt, Patrick Wilson, Elizabeth Reaser, Collette Wolfe, Jill Eikenberry, and Richard Bekins. Distributed by Paramount Pictures. Rated R, with a running time of 94 minutes.
